Veg. Rebuttal

Stephen's picture

I posted a blog about a couple of the reasons that I am a vegetarian... First a rebuttal of a comment I recieved.

[i]"So you stop eating it?

There's plenty of space to go around, you know. This isn't Hong Kong or anything"[/i]
It depends on the perspective of the reader.
Still, as a humanist, I can't imagine eatting something that requires more food than I do [b]just to be produced[/b]!
It seems wasteful. But I don't think that it is immoral to eat meat or anything (as I made clear). I just prefer not to take liberties that I don't miss (the same with fuel consumption).

[i]"Meat is not unhealthy. What part of meat is unhealthy? Meat is the BEST source of protein and B12 on the planet. Plants do not satisfy our system as well as meat does."[/i]
Meat contains things like cholesterol and unsaturated fat that are either unnecessary (our body naturally produces all the cholesterol that we need) or dangerous (saturated fats contribute to heart diease, hyper-tension and increased blood pressure, among other things). I don't quiet understand what you mean by "satisfy our system."

Also, Meat isn't the BEST source of protein. The only animal source that even comes close to TVP (which is texturized soy protein) [b]is insects[/b]. So if you want to argue that the occasional fly-burger is good for the muscles then you would have me over a barrel.

"All chemical energy can be traced back to plants? What are you talking about?"

No animal can produce food, it is always traced to a producer.

"Why is it gross? We're supposed to eat it. Plants grow and move and stuff too... EW! Growing food! EW! Bacteria!":

Its called aesthetics. I find it gross, therefore it is (for me). IT IS A REASON I'M A VEGETARIAN, NOT AN ARGUEMENT FOR OTHERS!
I could also write about why I don't wear pink. It's personal taste.

"Meat is not any grosser than anything else. Your thinking is very selective, and there must be a reason why you think that, because humans naturally want (need) meat. So, why? "

OK:
I dislike meat..I find it gross. I don't think that there is a natural inclination in humans to eat meat, I think that we are able to in the same way that I am attracted to people of the same sex. It isn't that one preference is more natural than the other, since both (sexual and food tastes) are subjective.
And something being instinctive or natural doesn't imply that it is good.

"Have you been raised by vegetarian parents? Or just brainwashed by vegetarian groups?"

Hmmm

"Have you been raised by gay parents? Or just brainwashed by gay groups"
"Have you been raised by atheist parents? Or just brainwashed by atheist groups?"

The answer to both questions is no. My parents aren't veg. and I am associated with no veg. groups.

"I'd think the latter, since you seem very ignorant on the subject. I suggest you stop taking people's words for things, wise up a bit, and go eat a burger or something."

Please do not condesend to me. I have not and will not judge you (or call you a tool) because you eat meat.

Funny thing you get all

Funny thing you get those comments about brainwashing from atheists (who might hear them as well)... come on people, all minorities get bashed, We should support each other! The only thing that should consider you is maintaining a healthy vegetarian diet, which is very possible.

GeneralRamos's picture

Agreed! So long as

Agreed! So long as vegitarians aren't forcing you to live that way, I see no issue with it. I don't see any really unsound reasoning in being a vegitarian, but it's a matter of choice as to what you want to eat.

Bloody_Cavum's picture

Soy is a terrible source of

Soy is a terrible source of protein. it contains phytoestrogens, which, unless you're a post-menopausal woman, are not good. In men, though this probably applies most (perhaps only applies) to men in puberty, it can shrink your penis and testicles, and promote the development of breasts. Soy also contains Phytates, which inhibits the body's ability to effectively utilize minerals and nutrients. Soy also inhibits the body's ability to use protein. On a side note, most soy crops are sprayed with pesticides, and, on top of that, many soy bean plants are from genetically engineered crops. I do not believe that consuming large amounts of soy can have emasculating effects in post-pubescent men, however, I am not sure. There are reasons bodybuilders and weightlifeters do not use soy and get their protein from better sources, namely whey, egg whites, and certain types of meat. not all meats are created equal; chicken, beef, and fish are good sources of protein that the body rapidly assimilates. Pork, on the other hand, takes many hours. Being a vegetarina is fine, but remember -- humans evolved as omnivores and should eat as such.

Stephen's picture

I am all for a balanced

I am all for a balanced diet, don't get me wrong. I was speaking specifically to TVP which contains soy, but is really what it is an acronym for, namely Texurised Vegetable Protein. It is almost its weight in protein pound for pound (though it tastes kind-uh like spounge).

As for the other facts you mentioned n soy, I'll be reading up on that.

"Being a vegetarina is fine, but remember -- humans evolved as omnivores and should eat as such."

I dunno about that one. I mean I agree that humans are capable of eating a variety of things, I just don't think that is necessarily a good reason to.

Bloody_Cavum's picture

well indeed, the fact that

well indeed, the fact that we're capable of eating something doesn't necessecarily mean that we should. now, should humans eat meat? i can't say whether we should or not, however, I can say with great certainty that we have the intestinal tract of a carnivore -- it's short. animals that're purely herbavore have longer intestines because it takes longer to digest fibre, and on top of that, most pure herbavores have multiple stomachs. does this say you should eat meat? absolutely not. i cannot argue as to whether you, as an individual, should eat meat. all i can say is that the human digestive system is perfectly capable, no, [i]designed[/i] to handle meat intake. my dad has been a life long vegetarian. i've eaten tvp and i don't like the texture much. it is to my understanding that tvp is essentially compressed soyflour (or what is left of the bean after the oil is extracted.) is this correct?

Stephen's picture

I think so. And I agree

I think so. And I agree about the texture.. blech. It is just eww. (again my subjective view... I feel wierd having to mention that).

I also agree that our intestine were designed by natural selection (I don't like the implications of the word "designed" but I agree that it is appropriate) to consume meat.